Featured

8. On the exhaustion of living with one foot in the closet

No one prepares you for the exhaustion of being queer and closeted at work. 

There’s the waking up early, the hell commute, the bus that doesn’t arrive, the rude coworkers, the overbearing boss, and a host of other things to worry about. Then there’s the constant misgendering, the wince of hearing girl and she and her all day long, the sweet relief of coming home to your roommates and finally hearing they again. Being queer but not out is an exhaustion that is hard to describe; it’s different from normal work burnout that comes from stress over deadlines or projects. It’s stress from constant fear that you’ll be outed, judged, and maybe fired. 

In college classes when a professor misgenders me, there’s always a knowing friend to either give me a sympathetic look, correct the teacher, or say something after class. In the workplace, there’s no one. 

I must have spent an hour on my second day at my summer job editing my employee profile; one other employee had “she/they” as their pronouns. Most people didn’t include pronouns at all. And I had yet to see another coworker refer to this person as anything but she. Odds are that no one would even notice if I added they/them to my bio, because no one really looked at anyone else’s bio. I agonized over it for an hour anyways, before deciding to just leave it blank. 

It’s strange how I can be out to strangers on the street but not my coworkers. I went to pride in a binder and a skirt with nothing else, and didn’t care who saw me. But god forbid my cubicle-mate should learn that I’m not 100% girl, 100% of the time. 

The problem isn’t even that my workplaces are too old to understand, or that it’s a generational gap. That does concern me, because I know the middle aged mother of three who sits across from me thinks that being trans is fake, let alone genderfluid. But even among my younger coworkers, I worry that they’ll see me differently, especially as an intern— I’m the weird, hyper-liberal college student who just wants to be unique. It’s frustrating being a representative of an entire group of people, whether that be my age demographic, my college in particular, or college students in general. If I’m a “special snowflake” for wanting to go by they/them, then I start coloring people’s perceptions of other interns who are not me, and I don’t want that.

I also worry about the fact that it’s something I could be rejected from a job for. On applications, usually they just ask for your gender and offer male or female. Occasionally they provide a “decline to answer” option. But I fear that declining to answer will get my application automatically thrown in a “no” pile for being too feminist or problematic for not wanting to answer their binary question. On applications that offer a fill in the blank or additional options for gender, I always check off female anyways. The fear that my divergent answer will land my unseen resume in the trash is enough to scare me into misrepresenting myself on every application I submit. 

Last year I attended a journalism conference and saw a panel where the speaker, a gender nonconforming journalist, spoke about their experience in the workplace writing for the LA times. Afterwards I went up to them and asked how they did it, how they handled being out, especially in an industry that’s stuck in the past and its old ways. Their advice, while valued, didn’t really help because of our geographic differences; it’s one thing to be gender nonconforming in a Los Angeles newsroom, and an entirely different thing to be genderfluid at a Boston newspaper, a town and industry rooted in tradition. 

I hate that my gender is a political issue, because it shouldn’t be— to say that I am my gender is not to make a political statement, it’s just being who I am. To take my gender, something about me that I cannot change and did not choose, and to say that accepting my gender is a political move, is to invalidate the fact of my upbringing and my reality. I was raised in a strict Roman Catholic household with a republican mother and a progressive independent father. Their views did not make me genderfluid, I just am. 

The exhaustion that comes from living a double, even triple life can be excruciating. You have to keep track of which people know and which don’t, where you’re out and where you’re not, what could happen if you were outed in this place vs this one. Will this person let something slip to my parents or employer? Who do I need to tell to misgender me at this event or with these people? It’s not just the exhaustion of being misgendered— it’s having to go to every friend who you are out to, and tell them, “Listen, I need you to call me she/her when ___ arrives or when we visit this person.” 

You have to constantly monitor who knows what and what they can hear. I have a friend visiting from back home who is one of my closest and best friends since childhood— but I’m not out to her because I know she wouldn’t understand, and I value our friendship too much to put strain on it from coming out. Whenever I tell my other friends this, that I want to remain closeted to my best friend of 13 years and counting, they always say that if she rejected me over my gender, she wasn’t my friend to begin with. But that isn’t true— it isn’t that she would hate me for it, it’s that she doesn’t even have the concept of gender fluidity in her life. It isn’t something she has ever learned about or needed to understand. She comes from a place of ignorance, not hate. 

And I’m so tired of having to educate my friends. It’s exhausting. Correcting pronouns is exhausting, so after a while you just give up, because what more are you going to say? “Hey I know I’ve told you 30 times, but let me just tell you 30 more— those aren’t my pronouns.” The burden falls entirely on queer people to be a constant reminder to our friends— “Don’t call me that, don’t say that, don’t refer to me that way.” Which is what makes it so much harder, after they’ve finally gotten it, to then turn around and say, “Actually, when my sister visits, can you use she?” 

There’s no polite way to ask your friends to please just do their own research, please learn to be better about this without me having to coach you through it, please don’t then turn into the weird social justice friend who always jumps to correct people on pronouns to be some performative woke hero. I don’t need you to be my hero, I just need you to respect me. 

There’s so much labor that goes into living life partially in the closet— at work, at school, with friends, with family. It’s mind games all day long, constant calculations, back and forth and trying to keep everything from falling apart. So the next time you misgender a trans person, or ask them why they snap at you when you get it wrong, or ask them why they’ve given up on correcting people, try to remember that in addition to our lives as students, as employees, as friends and siblings and children and parents, we are also laboring every minute of every day just to feel comfortable in our own skin and make it by day by day in this society. 

9. On the wonder of insignificance and individuality

It’s been awhile since I’ve written something, so apologies for that. Without going into too much detail, I moved to a new place, lacerated my hand, had some stitches, got a root canal, and have finally settled down. So now it’s back to writing!

My hiatus actually inspired me to write this current piece, because while I had my stitched up hand I couldn’t hold a pencil to physically write with— I could only type, one handed at first, and eventually very carefully with both hands. But when I finally was able to hold a pencil and write with it this past week, I was thrilled— which is strange, because I’ve always preferred typing to writing. 

But there was something so instinctual and satisfying about writing with a pencil and paper, the kind of individual beauty that comes from producing your own words, not just with a computer, but uniquely your own words— ones that you crafted, that are shaped the way you want them. As much as we have computer fonts to change things up and express ourselves, nothing is as unique or beautiful as someone’s individual handwriting. 

I’ve been thinking a lot about individuality these days. Whenever I walk down the street alone, I’m overwhelmed by the revelation that everyone around me is living their own life, independent of mine, dealing with their own highs and lows, successes and failures. It’s very strange to think about how insignificant you are in that sense— and at the same time, it’s wonderfully comforting to know that no matter how bad you screw things up, you’re just one person in a whole sea of people. Living in a city makes you think like this. 

But it’s true, individuality is scary and fascinating at the same time. There’s a word, I’m not sure if it’s a real word or not, that stands for this feeling: it’s called “sonder.” It means that you suddenly recognize the amazing fact that everyone around you is living in their own personal world shaped around themselves— we are all the center of our own universe. I love that word, and I love what it means, and I think it might be the writer in me but I constantly think about it, and I always want to ask people about themselves. 

Whenever I’m on the bus, or walking to work, or just wandering around the neighborhood, and I look at someone and realize that they have this whole world, this whole story contained inside of them, I just want to stop and ask them to tell me everything. I just wish I could absorb everyone’s stories into me, know what they all go through— and of course, that’s impossible, and would definitely drive me crazy, because the stories I do know are always on my mind. People I’ve lost, people I love, everyone who’s story I know, even if it’s only a tiny fraction, I constantly wonder about how the world looks to them, how they look to the world, whether they’ll remember me after I forget them. 

I’ve had a couple interactions recently with people who I have met once or twice, and I remembered them and they looked through me like I wasn’t even there. At first it just annoyed me that I put effort into remembering these people’s faces and names and they couldn’t do the same for me, but eventually it just reminded me of how wrapped up we are in ourselves, and how we really do just see ourselves as the protagonist of our own life plot— and why shouldn’t we? Our own life is what we know best. What matters is that we remember there are billions of other lives and plots playing out all around us— and they all have something to share.  

7. On shaving and body hair

I was 10 years old when I approached my mother with the question, “Mom, can I start shaving my legs?” I have a very vivid memory of going to school that year, only in fourth grade, and sitting on the carpet with my hairy legs folded criss-cross. I looked around me, and as far as I could tell, every other girl in the room either didn’t have leg hair, or it was so light that it wasn’t noticeable. 

I, on the other hand, had such dark, thick, coarse hair that my legs resembled that of a high school boy gone through puberty. I went home that day and popped the question. 

My mom made a feeble effort to tell me I didn’t need to start shaving, but quickly gave in. She knew the shame I was feeling; her arms were covered in the same thick, dark coat that mine were, and she had been using Nair on her legs and face for as long as I could remember. 

She took me up to the bathroom and showed me how to use shaving cream, to shave in one direction, to moisturize my skin afterwards. I cut myself more than a few times as I learned— my legs were covered in dried blood spots for weeks on end. Eventually, I started to hate the hair on my body in other places, too— my arms, my happy trail on my stomach, my back, everywhere. 

One day in the summer when I was 12 years old, I shaved off all my stomach hair because I was going to a pool party. I wanted to have the smooth, clean, perfect body of all the white girls who would be there. Still, despite my best efforts, I had noticeably more hair than every other girl in attendance. 

It took me 9 years after I started shaving for me to stop hating my body hair. I let my happy trail grow back in, I left my legs unshaven for weeks and months on end, I stopped hyper fixating on whether or not to wax my arms. 

Body hair is stigmatized for women to such an insane degree, and every woman knows the shame of being told by her friends or family that she needs to shave. But I found it to be an especially unbearable stigma because of my coloring. I would complain to my light-skinned friends about how I couldn’t even afford to go one day without shaving, because my hair grew so dark, thick, and fast. They would give me one of two responses, both of which stung. 

The first response was, “Oh, me too! I have soooo much hair. I mean, look at my legs, isn’t this ridiculous? So embarrassing.” I would look at their legs and see the tiniest wisp of blonde hair that you needed a microscope to properly see. I hated that they were trying to identify with me when they could have gone their whole lives without shaving, and no one would know. It also terrified me, knowing that if they thought their bleach-blonde barely-there hair was that bad, what must they be thinking of me? I felt like an animal standing next to an angel. 

The other response, which almost hurt more, would be, “Oh, I don’t shave. I don’t really have to.” It made me insanely jealous, knowing that just because of the way someone’s appearance was from birth, they could go their whole life not having to deal with the pain and shame that comes with body hair removal for dark-haired girls. 

The advent of the cultural shift in body hair stigma both pleased and upset me. I came to a liberal college in the city and met girls who told me they had never shaved, that they were fighting the patriarchy, that of course they wouldn’t remove their hair, and part of me found it very inspiring and empowering. But all that time that I had been ripping out my follicles, I wasn’t thinking of appeasing a man. I just wanted to be normal. 

I was fighting an internal battle with myself. A battle brought on, of course, by a male dominated world that demanded women be hairless and perfect. But my thinking had never been about being sexy or appealing— it had always been that I just wanted to be like everyone else. And by everyone else, I meant every light-skinned and light-haired girl. 

I don’t mean to claim that light-haired women and girls aren’t shamed for their body hair. The entire culture of forcing women to remove hair that grows naturally is an abhorrence in itself. I just wish I could go back to myself at ten years old, staring longingly at the bare legs of my classmates, and tell myself, “You are beautiful. No amount of shaving or waxing or chemicals is ever worth it. You are enough.” 

6. On tactile sensitivity and neurodivergence

Trying to describe tactile sensitivities to someone who has never experienced it is insanely difficult. Similar to the well-known quote, “Writing about music is like dancing about architecture,” trying to explain why I can’t wear jeans or touch velvet is something that I just can’t explain sometimes. 

I’ve tried writing about it in every way possible. I’ve tried writing poems, stories, physically trying to make people feel what I feel when my hands are too dry and I touch a rough fabric, why I absolutely need to moisturize my hands after I shower, why I wear gloves to do the dishes, why I do, in fact, need to cut the tags off of my clothing. 

Even as I type this, the feeling of my computer surface against my hands is making me clench my teeth and bite my lip. 

I am constantly looking for smooth metal or plastic surfaces to place my hands on or wrap my fingers around to dissipate the feeling of dry, uncomfortable sensation that comes from any number of sources. I could go on and on about the number of things that cause me physical discomfort to touch: fabric bus seats, construction paper, velvet, wool, corduroy, dry hands, nail files. Just typing them out and thinking about it makes me nauseous. 

There’s no rhyme or reason to why these specific materials cause me so much discomfort; they just do, and it’s always been that way. I’ve tried googling it and found online forums of people also looking for help, for something to explain why this material or that one makes their teeth hurt and stomach churn. I think all of us just want to know why we are the way we are. 

I’ve seen it called tactile sensitivity, tactile defensiveness, and sensory defensiveness. Regardless of the name you give it, it affects everyone differently and is impossible to explain to those who haven’t experienced it. 

When I tell people I don’t wear jeans, they often think it’s weird but don’t question it. What I don’t explain is that if I do wear jeans, any movement I make all day long will have me biting the inside of my cheek and pressing my lips together. When I was younger, my mom used to think I was just being difficult when I wanted the tags cut off my clothes. But when she would leave the tags on, I couldn’t focus on anything all day because I was constantly tugging at the back of my shirt. I once ripped holes in three different shirts in the course of a week from pulling out the tags. 

Hypersensitivity to materials often comes with other neurological disorders or symptoms; for me, I tend to hyperfocus on activities and interactions, fixating on small details and analyzing conversations over and over. When I’m assigned an activity or project, I can’t rest until it’s done. Sometimes this fixation on completeness is helpful, like in school when I need to get something done quickly. Sometimes it’s frustrating, though, when I ask someone to do a favor or project and they put it off; I know that procrastination is only human nature, but my brain has trouble processing why someone would deliberately avoid doing something they know they need to do. It’s in times like those when I have to remind myself that my brain does not function the same way, and I can’t blame people for taking their time/putting things off. 

Neurodivergence is a difficult subject to write about, but I think I’ve taken a fairly good stab at it here. What are your thoughts? Can you relate to issues of hypersensitivity or fixation? How do you deal with this in everyday life?

5. On racial identity influencing our greater selves

Being third generation is a strange place to be. I look identical to my Grandma, who is 100% Lebanese, even though I’m only a quarter. I’m the only one in my family who has these olive skinned looks. I have one sister and six other cousins, and of the eight of us on this side of the family, not one of them inherited the Lebanese looks except for me. Why me? Did I lose the genetic lottery? I wonder about this a lot. 

I also wonder about how much being the only Lebanese-looking cousin, but essentially being raised white, influenced who I am— not just as a person, but in my mindset, my sexuality, my gender, everything. I feel that I am living in a constant in-between state in everything I do. 

I am not Arab enough for the Arab students at school, but around my white friends I constantly feel the divide between us. But if I were to ever attempt to befriend the Arab students at my college, I would be immediately identified as an outsider. I come from a white area, with a white name, raised in a white culture, in a Catholic family. I am not Muslim, I don’t speak Arabic. I don’t have all the hallmarks of what it means to be an Arab, so it doesn’t matter that I’m Lebanese— I will never be Arab enough. 

But my white friends don’t understand or believe me when I tell them that I get pulled for random security checks at airports all too frequently. They tell me they envy my olive skin and the fact that I don’t burn, even though as a child I was teased for being yellow skinned, with thick dark arm hair. I introduce my friends to Lebanese food and they’re blown away, finding it just so interesting, and how had they never tried this before? My family’s culture is entirely foreign to them— but I’m still not Arab enough. 

In my family, everyone wants to pretend that my Mommom isn’t who she is. The few times I can get her to talk about her heritage, I learn things I never knew— that she spoke Aramaic growing up, that she used to only eat home cooked Lebanese food, that she had relatives in a strong Lebanese community in Rhode Island. I pull these tidbits from her slowly and carefully, learning in flashes about her childhood. But at the same time, she rails against immigrants and refugees, saying that they’re all ruining our country. I wonder how she forgets so easily who she is.

I constantly find myself comparing myself to my other mixed friends, wondering when I’m going to be immediately recognizably Arab. No one has ever guessed it right on their first try.

I wonder if I so desperately threw myself into the queer community because it was the first community where I was finally enough of something to feel like I could belong. I wasn’t this half something, half another, imposter in every way possible. I was queer, fully and completely, bisexual and genderfluid. I knew I had a place in this community. 

And yet I still find ways to doubt myself. I dress too feminine, I’m too cisgender-passing. I don’t wear my chest binder enough to call myself nonbinary. I’ve been in relationships with girls and guys, but when I say I’m with a man, I feel like people think I’m not truly bisexual. When I started dating my current boyfriend, my old roommate would make comments about how “straight” our relationship is— even though we’re both queer. 

I don’t know where this constant feeling of imposter syndrome comes from. I don’t know if it stems from this need to be a part of something that drives all human experience, or whether it has something to do with my ethnicity, but it frustrates me to no end— and I can’t seem to find a way to just be happy with living in the middle in this society that so frequently assigns us categories to self-identify down to the tiniest detail. 

4. On the broad category of ‘Asian’

Discourse surrounding the Asian continent and the use of the word “Asian” as a racial identifier has become more inclusive over the last decade or so. Typically, when people say someone is/looks Asian, what they mean is that they look East Asian— Chinese, Japanese, Filipino, etc. And most non-Asians use this general descriptor because they don’t bother to differentiate between the different nationalities and ethnicities that make up the Asian continent. 

In recent years, however, this has started to expand into reminding people that Asia is not just China and Japan, but includes southern Asian countries as well, such as India, Thailand, Burma, etc. However, among this discourse reminding people that Southeast Asians are also part of Asia, southwest Asians are left behind— not just in this discourse, but in others as well.

In the United States, anyone who can be categorized as MENA (Middle East and North Africa) does not have the option to choose this on the national census, college applications, or job applications. The United States categorized Middle Eastern and North African people, such as Syrians, Egyptians, etc, as white. The category on the census or, for example, the common application for colleges, lists the option as “White/Caucasian (including Middle Eastern origin)”. So in the U.S., even though MENA people are the target of hate crimes, whose representatives are accused of being terrorists, they are counted as white in the census. 

This in-between state develops for Arab peoples; we aren’t considered Asian because we aren’t East Asian, we aren’t considered white by people who want us to leave the U.S., but we have to call ourselves white because the U.S. census deems it so. 

It might seem silly to be upset over something like this, the fact that Arab people don’t have a neat box to fit themselves into when it comes to racial and ethnic categories. But the issue is not over wanting a label and not having one; it’s over being actively disqualified from a category because you aren’t enough of something. Geographically, the Middle East occupies space in the same way that it does in popular discourse on Asian diasporas and studies; it is in limbo, in between continents, on the edge of one thing and almost another. 

This displacement, combined with the effects of imperialization and colonization still scarring these countries, forms an effect of being placed in a category all its own with established connotations about what it means to be Arab but not Asian. 

Stereotypes come to mind when you hear both of those words; Asian calls to mind the typical assumptions about high intelligence, a specific demographic (Chinese/Japanse), parental discipline, tourists, etc. Arab calls to mind the Islamic religion, terrorism, refugees, etc. You can see the marked difference between calling someone Asian and calling them Arab or Middle Eastern— even though Arabs are Asian. For both of these categories, the stereotypes are wildly offensive and untrue; not every Arab is Muslim, but the world perceives it to be that way. 

Readers of my blog will know that I place great emphasis on linguistic patterns and how our language shapes our world. While this may seem like an insignificant signifier, whether or not we categorize Arabs as Asian, I feel that it does matter greatly that in the U.S., we are denying this group of people their identity while excluding them from another.

3. On ‘other’ parts of America

Going to school in a liberal environment in a liberal city is really interesting most of the time, because my hometown is nothing like this. Back home, Trump signs are more common than stop signs. The day I got back from my first year of college, there was a protest outside my old high school with people holding signs calling our students sinners because our principal was a “f*g”. Although the town is technically in a swing district, we consistently vote red. Several years ago, the school board considered not teaching climate change anymore in our science curriculum, and if they did want to keep it, they would have to offer “both sides of the argument.” 

Moving from that kind of environment to my college was a shocking but welcome transition, to a place where not only students, but sometimes professors, would ask my pronouns. A place where I was not the only Arab student, a place where the words “post-colonialism” and “microaggression” were considered valid in a classroom discourse. 

I loved this new environment, this new school, this new feeling of finally being somewhere that didn’t feel like constant suffocation. But I discovered the other day, when talking to a friend from the same state as me, also from a rural area, that people at my college really have no idea how they sound when they criticize “other parts of the country.” 

A common refrain in classroom discussions will often be something along the lines of, “You know, in some places in America, they teach creationism instead of evolution.” “You know, in some states, they don’t even have sex education at all in high school.” 

I mean, can you imagine? What barbaric land could they possibly be talking about? 

Probably my school. Or my friend’s school. I was taught abstinence only sex education— nothing about consent, nothing about sex itself, or about STIs. Just don’t do it, they said. My friend was taught that creationism is the truth, that evolution is a hoax.

And look at us now, both of us fine, both of us recognizing that just because we were educated in a certain way or grew up in a certain area doesn’t make us dumb or ignorant. White educated liberals need to end this narrative of pity, othering, and generalizations about what they perceive to be the unfortunate souls living in conservative areas. 

We see this narrative a lot about southern states, where people from northern states will make sweeping claims about inbred southerners and stupid white people in Alabama— largely ignoring the significant and heavily disenfranchised black population of the south. 

I’ve found that at institutions of higher education, the desire to make assumptions about rural or conservative areas often disregards many of the statistics about that area’s actual demographics. And it doesn’t come from a place of teasing, but often a position of arrogance, or even pity. 

Those poor, poor people don’t know any better and are just so unlucky to be born into these backwards towns, stuck in the past. If only they had been born in our super liberal, super affluent town— in this town, we raise pride flags at our state buildings. Can you believe there are gay people living in rural America who are just so scared to live their truth? I feel so bad for them. 

Fun fact— there are more queer people in rural America than you realize, and while it’s scary to come out and live boldly in places that aren’t as tolerant, it doesn’t mean we want your pity— it means we want your admiration and respect, just like any queer person who boldly lives their truth. 

The distance and pity that comes from urban elites in their opinions about small towns and rural areas is an easy trap to fall into. But when you take a second to step back and think about the fact that your assumptions about demographics and intelligence might come from a place of bias, you’ll realize that you’ve been forgetting to count all of us living here, in the background, trying to make our voices heard. 

2. On the excuse of “It’s not how they were raised”

Many times when I’ve been misgendered by older people, or even by people my age, a common refrain I hear from people is that using they/them pronouns is just such a wildly foreign concept that you can’t blame people for getting it wrong over and over. “It’s not how they were raised,” people say. They say that it’s just too hard to change your linguistic constructs after the age of what, 25? 30? 

Not only do I think this is disrespectful to myself and people who misgender me, I think it’s flat out wrong in its assumptions about linguistic evolution. 

First of all, the fact that we’re saying that older people should be exempt from keeping in touch with language changes suggests that they just don’t have the brain capacity to handle it. They’re too dumb, too slow, whatever you want to say. But we can get older people to stop saying the n-word, right? We can get them to use words like “selfie” and “hashtag” and other modern hallmarks of language. And older people have been using they/them as pronouns for years, just as all English speakers have, just not in the context that we now ask them to— they’re used to using it for groups of people or for an unknown person. But it’s not as if this is an entirely new word being introduced to language— it’s just being used in a new way. 

Furthermore, the excuse of saying that just because someone wasn’t raised this way means that they can’t ever learn anything new excuses behavior that we know is wrong. If we look at older people and say, “Oh, well it’s new to them, give them some time,” it’s fine when we’re referring to using correct pronouns. But if the old person is repeatedly referring to gay people with the f-slur, we wouldn’t lovingly say, “Oh, but I get it, it’s how they were raised.” We would say no, hard stop, that word is not okay anymore. 

The reality is, we make concessions for adjusting pronouns because it isn’t seen as a valid enough reason to make linguistic accommodations. Why should people care what you want to be called when it has no effect on them personally? 

Just because someone was raised to say things a certain way does not make their action, or inaction, excusable. What part of our society suggests that we should never adopt anything new or try to change old harmful traditions? Are we still churning our own butter? Still relegating women to the kitchen and nowhere else? Why is progress in linguistics that much harder than progress in other areas?

The excuse of “It’s new to them, it’s not how they were raised” is a feasible explanation for the first one or two times that someone misgenders me. 5, 6, 7 times later, I start to lose my patience. More than 10 times later, I know it has nothing to do with the way someone was raised, and everything to do with a deliberate choice to not make the effort to adjust their way of thinking. At that point, I know the misgendering, while maybe not deliberately malicious, comes from a place of lack of caring whether or not they got it right. And that lackadaisical “who cares” attitude is just as bad as deliberate misgendering— it means the fact of my comfort and security in my gender doesn’t even mean enough to you to cross your mind. 

1. On the language of “identifying as”

Language, identity, place, home: these are all of a piece— just different elements of belonging and not-belonging.

— Jhumpa Lahiri

Someone recently proudly told me all about how she understands gender identity. She told me, “Someone asked me if I was a girl, and I said, ‘Yes, but it’s because I identify as a girl.’”

I honestly don’t know what to make of this statement. I don’t know if she expected me to see this as some bold thing to say, or whether I should thank her endlessly for her allyship. What I wanted to do, though, is say, “What do you mean ‘but I identify as a girl?’”

I take issue with the language of people saying “they/she/he identifies as _____.” It suggests that gender is some sort of thing trans people just put on, while knowing the real truth about ourselves. “I’m a girl, but I identify as nonbinary.” That’s not true. I’m not a girl. When I say what I am, it’s because I mean that to be the truth. 

I don’t just project this genderfluid identity onto myself and say “I know what I really am, but this is what I would like to be.” If that was the case, I would just dress non-conforming. I don’t ask people to use my pronouns out of preference. They are not my “preferred” pronouns for a gender “identity.” They are my pronouns for my gender, plain and simple. 

The issue with this, though, is that the language of identification is something we cling to so closely, and I don’t know when it started— “I identify as Middle Eastern. I identify as bisexual.” It’s a very common phrase, and to me it seems to put this barrier between how we see ourselves and how we project an image of ourselves. When I think of my gender, I don’t think of it as an identity. Saying “I identify as genderfluid” puts this extra step between my inner thoughts and feelings and the reality of the world by suggesting my gender is a charade. 

I do understand the argument/reasoning behind using the language of identity, though. Our identities are so important to us, that we find ways every day to self-identify, not just in gender or sexuality, but in many other ways— our job titles, our hometowns, what sports teams we support, where we stood on the social ladder in high school. And yet, we would never say we “identify” as any of these things. I would never tell someone, “I identified as a nerd in high school.” I would just say, “Yeah, in high school, I was kind of a loser.” It is still part of my identity, though, the fact that I was never a popular kid. So why do we assign the “I identify” qualifier to only certain aspects of identity, like gender? 

It’s these linguistic oddities that fascinate me when it comes to gender and sexuality. Not sure if I’ve captured everything I wanted to in this post, but I think I took a good stab at it. Until next time. 

Introduction

So you made it to my site! Welcome. This is my space for letting out my thoughts on all that frustrates me in life about my own existence and others’ as it pertains to identity—the nebulous and undefined nature of gender, sexuality, and race/ethnicity.

Why make this blog?

  • There’s something very comforting about talking to a friend late at night and saying all the deep thoughts you would never say in daylight. I’d like this blog to be something like that for me.
  • If even one person out there could read this and relate to it, I would feel satisfied with my efforts.
  • I would have liked something like this to turn to growing up.

I hope others can see this blog as a sort of forum for putting thoughts out there on subjects that none of us fully understand. I don’t intend for this blog to be the final say on anything political or theoretical; I don’t mean to make myself out to be an expert on anything that I write about. I just find catharsis in putting these thoughts and feelings into words, and trying to understand where they come from.

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started